Behind the Mask: The Rise of Leslie Vernon is a 2006 American mockumentary black comedy slasher directed by Scott Glosserman and starring Nathan Baesel, Angela Goethals, Scott Wilson, Zelda Rubinstein, and the legend himself, Robert Englund. It is an homage to the slasher genre, following a journalist and her crew as they document an aspiring serial killer who models himself after classic slasher film conventions.

The film uses a mockumentary style, blending interviews and behind-the-scenes footage in a way that blurs the line between fiction and reality. The effect is totally unique and really clever.

Let me start by saying this is not my first time watching it. I have probably seen Behind the Mask about 300 times, but I had to finally review it. It is one of my all-time favourites, and here is why.

This film is unlike anything else in horror. I honestly think it is criminally underrated. It is not easy to make a movie that parodies a genre in a way that fans of that genre still love, while also being a solid entry in the genre itself. Somehow, Behind the Mask pulls it off.

It is genuinely funny. Nathan Baesel, who plays Leslie Vernon, is perfect in the role. He is so charming and committed that you cannot help but root for him through the first half of the film, right up until everything shifts. Journalist Taylor, played by Angela Goethals, follows Leslie with her crew as he explains his plans and the obstacles he faces, like needing to train constantly just to keep up with his victims while still looking like he is casually walking. It is hilarious, but it is also tense because you start to wonder if the crew is really going to just stand by and let him kill a bunch of horny teenagers. And if they do not, what happens to them?

While it is not terrifying in the traditional sense because you actually get to know the slasher, there are still plenty of suspenseful moments and a few unexpected turns.

The brilliance of Behind the Mask is in its meta narrative. Leslie, with his folksy charm and surprisingly insightful commentary, breaks down the genre while fully leaning into it. You learn about mask maintenance, the psychology of final girls, and the importance of a good stalking technique, all delivered with a knowing wink.

But do not be fooled by the humour. The film knows how to build dread. As Leslie carefully creates his own legend, the line between the documentary and reality starts to blur. Is he performing, or are the crew so deep in it that they cannot see the real monster emerging?

Leslie himself is a standout character. Baesel gives him a sincerity that makes him oddly likeable and genuinely disturbing. He is not just some mindless killer. He is a craftsman, an artist with a passion for what he does. Honestly, Leslie Vernon might be the most well-developed slasher villain I have seen in a long time.

Behind the Mask is not just a love letter to slasher films. It is also a sharp satire and a clever take on why these stories still pull us in. It is funny, it is creepy, and it will have you rethinking everything you thought you knew about masked killers.

Also, how can I not mention Robert Englund, Freddy Krueger himself, who plays Doc Halloran, a doctor who once treated Leslie in Reno. He steps into a kind of Van Helsing role, trying to warn and stop what is coming. His presence adds even more horror credibility. There are also awesome cameo appearances from Kane Hodder, who played Jason Voorhees in Friday the 13th, and Zelda Rubinstein, who played Tangina in Poltergeist. If you are a horror fan like me, I’m sure you will absolutely love those touches.

All in all, this film is just plain fun. It has everything you want from a horror flick. Clever writing, great performances, suspense, laughs, and a ton of genre love.

I am so happy I got to watch it again. And again. And again.

5 out of 5

A must-watch for horror lovers who think they have seen it all.

Like this review? I work really hard putting these together, so if you’d like to support me, you can buy me a coffee at coff.ee/hauntsyoulater — I promise to spend it on caffeine and horror films only 🩸